A colleague and I were lamenting the state of paper discussants the other day. Seldom do we faculty teach graduate students how to be professionals. Even more seldom are we examples of brevity and wit. With that in mind, we came up with a list of tips for the budding academic:
1. Start by telling people why they should care. It is seldom obvious. What’s the big question, and what’s at stake if the paper gets it right or wrong?
2. Then summarize the paper. Break it down differently than the presenter. Pretend you are explaining it to your grandmother. Or, rather, your adult-attention-deficit-disorder grandmother. Keep it short.
3. Say more with less. Mathematically, everything you say after your best point lowers the average quality of your comment. Pick your three best points, say them briefly, then stop talking.
4. Now, say even less. Those three comments? Write out, in bullets, exactly what you plan to say. Now cross out half. What you think will take eight minutes will take fifteen. Bring it back to eight.
5. Be constructive. A colleague once said to me: “I like it when people find problems with my paper, but I like solutions more.” Finding solutions makes you think (and displays it too).
6. Don’t discuss the small stuff. Write your little comments down, and later give them to the author. Don’t bore the audience with footnotes and trivia.
7. Feel free to entertain. A discussant need not merely list ideas. You can weave in an anecdote, or frame a point with a story. At least speak from a personal point of view, not a monotone benevolent overlord.
8. Have fun, don’t make fun. If you use humor, let it not be at the expense of anyone but yourself.
9. Spell it out for us. Tell us why your comments matter. Say precisely what we learn.
10. Aim for profound. The best discussants rotate my brain 90 degrees. They reframe the problem, or propose a novel idea. I can’t tell you how to be deep. I seldom succeed myself. For me, a few things usually help. I read the paper, walk away for a day or two, then return. I ask myself questions: Do I think about a big question differently now? What convinces me, and what would convince me more? Where should the field be going?
Comments welcome.
75 Responses
Looking for a free music portal to enjoy your favorite tracks at any time? Use the link http://mp3ss.net, and you will open a huge media library – only the most popular and famous artists of different genres are represented here.
For the convenience of users, we have divided the music into categories. We can listen to you in public:
– New tracks. Our service staff is constantly working on updating the music site so you can enjoy the best hits, even if they came out quite recently. Would you like to be informed of the latest novelties in the chosen genre? Opening the section called “What’s New”, any site visitor can listen to the latest tracks.
– Hits. Do you often want to immerse yourself in the world of music, forgetting about all the problems and troubles? Choose this section, which presents hits of world artists, well known to any music lover. If you are a fan of modern parties, then the above The site will be extremely useful at any time of the day! For fans of modern music this section will also have to taste, as we have collected here the most top songs of recent years.
– Top songs of the day. In this section you will find songs, which are most often listened to by the visitors of the site for the current day – you can listen to a selection of audio recordings at any convenient time. Specially developed rating I system allows you to determine the most popular and frequently listened tracks for the day.
– Nostalgia. Do you like old retro songs? \ Classic classics always come first? Then the above-mentioned section will be very useful for you. The Internet portal Mp3ss.net will help you to plunge into the pleasant memories of the past time.
In order to find the composition you are interested in, it does not take much time, Besides, the search can be performed by specifying the name of the song, artist or album name. If you want on our service, you can not only listen to your favorite hits online 24 hours a day, but also download them to your computer in one click. .net you can not just listen to your favorite tunes – we also offer download songs or entire albums to your computer for free.
Visit the Internet portal Mp3ss.net to get access to a huge audio library for free, that staying on our site will seem very comfortable to you, because we completely removed ads that could distract you from listening. There is also no need to go through the registration procedure, that we appreciate the time of its users by providing them with only the most simple and intuitive functionality .
Я ваще такова не видел!!!это круто!! gucci sneakers[/url]. I will definetly order those. what do you think?
I like the list a lot in principle. However, several of its points assume that the papers are actually made available to the discussant beforehand, something that I’ve learned not to count on.
Sometimes good comments are not good conversation starters. The best comments are both profound and useful starting points for a broader discussion.
These are all great examples of what it means to be a great discussant. But experience tells me few people seem to be able to adopt these characteristics. A better solution has been to retire the role of discussant!
thanks for this – it’s terrific. I’d maybe add – consider making 2 or 3 slides when appropriate. I’ve seen Lane Kenworthy do that (who in turn claimed to have learned it from M. Wallerstein) and his were (for this and other reasons) some of the best comments I’ve seen.
“Actually read the papers” seems like a good addition to the list. :)